Chapter 3 “The Son” Part I Discussion Questions With Responses

By /

Discussion Questions with Drafted Responses

Part A: Understanding the Core Principles

  1. Bishop Barron calls the Creed’s profession of faith in Jesus the “watershed” or “point of demarcation.” What does he mean by this, and why is this section so central to the Christian faith?
  • Draft Response: Barron describes this section as the “watershed” because “distinctively Christian faith begins and ends with a particular person, Jesus from Nazareth, recognized to be the Son of God”.1 It is the central claim upon which all other Christian doctrines depend. While belief in one God is shared by other faiths, the assertion of Jesus’s divine identity is the unique and defining core of Christianity. The entire intellectual and spiritual structure of the faith is built upon this confession.
  1. The Creed begins by calling Jesus “one Lord Jesus Christ.” Based on the summary, break down the theological significance of each of these three names/titles. What does each one reveal about who Jesus is?
  • Draft Response:
  • Jesus: This is his personal name, from the Hebrew Yehoshua, meaning “Yahweh saves.” It is a theological statement in itself, affirming that God is a savior and that humanity is in need of salvation. Barron notes that Jesus, in his person, is the “salving of the wound caused by false praise,” or sin.1
  • Christ: This is a title from the Greek Christos, meaning “Anointed One” (Messiah in Hebrew). It situates Jesus as the fulfillment of Israel’s expectations for a definitive king, priest, and prophet.
  • Lord: This title (Kyrios in Greek) is the most radical claim. It was the term used in the Greek Old Testament to translate the sacred name of God, YHWH. To call Jesus “Lord” was to identify him directly with the one God of Israel, making it a clear and powerful declaration of his divinity.1
  1. A major focus of this section of the Creed was to counter the Arian heresy. What was the core teaching of Arianism, and how do the phrases “born of the Father before all ages” and “begotten, not made” directly refute it?
  • Draft Response: The core teaching of Arianism was that the Son, while exalted, was a creature—the first and greatest of God’s creations, but a creation nonetheless. The Arian slogan was, “There was a time when he was not”.1 The Creed’s phrase “born of the Father before all ages” directly refutes this by positing an eternal, timeless relationship that exists outside of creation. The phrase “begotten, not made” strikes at the heart of the Arian position by defining the Son’s origin not as an act of creation by God’s will, but as an eternal procession from the Father’s very being.1
  1. Explain the crucial distinction between something being “begotten” and something being “made.” Why is this distinction so critical for our understanding of salvation?
  • Draft Response: The summary, citing St. Athanasius, explains that “what is begotten entirely participates in that from which it comes, whereas what is made only imperfectly participates in its source”.1 Barron uses analogies: the Son proceeds from the Father like “radiance from fire” or “wetness… from the nature of a fountain”.1 It is a necessary, eternal generation from the Father’s own nature. In contrast, “making” is an act of will toward something external. This distinction is critical for salvation because only God can save. If Jesus were “made,” he would be a creature and thus on the human side of the divide, himself in need of salvation. Because he is “begotten,” he is fully divine and can therefore be the source of salvation, bridging the gap between God and humanity.1
  1. What is the meaning of the Greek term homoousios (“consubstantial”), and why was it so important and controversial? According to Barron, what does this term reveal about the very nature of God?
  • Draft Response: Homoousios means “of the same substance” or “consubstantial.” It was the definitive term used at the Council of Nicaea to declare that the Son shares the one and the same divine substance as the Father.1 It was controversial because it left no room for the Arian view that the Son was merely of a
    similar substance. According to Barron, the term’s genius is that it reveals something profound about God’s nature. Instead of being a static, solitary monad, God is a “play of relationality” and “‘being toward another’ belongs to the very essence of God”.1 Ultimate reality is not simple unity, but a communion of persons in an eternal act of self-giving love.
  1. The summary states that the Incarnation was the work of two agents: the Holy Spirit and the Virgin Mary. What is the theological significance of each of their roles in this event?
  • Draft Response:
  • The Holy Spirit: The Spirit’s agency signifies that the Incarnation is a work of God’s own creative power (ruach Yahweh). It is a new creation, a “gracious divine initiative” that breaks into history from above.1
  • The Virgin Mary: Mary represents the necessary human cooperation with God’s plan. Her “yes” (fiat) is the moment of receptive faith that allows the divine initiative to take root within creation. Her virginity is a theological sign that Jesus is not a product of human striving but is a sheer gift from God.1
  1. What does the phrase “and became man” tell us about the nature of Jesus Christ? What does it not mean?
  • Draft Response: The phrase “and became man” points to the mystery of the hypostatic union, formally defined at the Council of Chalcedon. It means that the one divine person of the Son of God took on a complete human nature without ceasing to be God. He possesses two natures, divine and human, united “without confusion or change, without division or separation”.1 It does
    not mean that the Son of God “turned into” a man, which would imply a change in the divine nature. Rather, he assumed a human nature and joined it to his divine person.

Part B: Growing in Intimacy with Jesus

  1. The name “Jesus” means “Yahweh saves.” How does reflecting on the meaning of His personal name change the way you pray to Him or think about His role in your life?
  • Draft Response: Understanding that His very name declares His mission to save can make prayer more direct and hopeful. Instead of seeing salvation as an abstract concept, we can see it as Jesus’s personal identity. When we call on the name “Jesus,” we are invoking “Yahweh saves”.1 This can bring confidence in moments of struggle, temptation, or fear, knowing that we are calling on the one whose very being is the answer to our need for rescue. It frames our relationship with him not just as a student to a teacher, but as a person in need to their dedicated savior.
  1. To call Jesus “Lord” (Kyrios) was a radical declaration of his divinity. What areas of your life are easy to surrender to His lordship? What areas are more difficult?
  • Draft Response: This question invites personal reflection. One might find it easy to acknowledge Jesus as Lord of their spiritual life or Sunday worship. However, the title “Lord” implies sovereignty over everything. The challenge is to extend his lordship to areas we tend to control ourselves: our finances, career ambitions, relationships, personal time, and deepest fears. Acknowledging him as Kyrios—as God—means trusting his wisdom and authority over these more difficult areas, which requires a deeper level of surrender and faith.
  1. Barron explains that because the Son is homoousios with the Father, we learn that God’s very essence is relational—a “play of relationality” and a “being toward another”.1 How does knowing that God is an eternal communion of self-giving love affect your personal prayer and relationship with Him?
  • Draft Response: This understanding can transform prayer from a monologue directed at a solitary, distant deity into a participation in a dynamic, loving conversation. If God’s very being is relational, then He desires a relationship with us. Prayer becomes less about reciting formulas and more about entering into the “play of relationality” that is the inner life of the Trinity. It means our relationship with God is not an addition to His life, but an invitation into the very love that He is. This can make prayer feel more like a homecoming than a duty.
  1. Mary’s “yes” represented humanity’s faith-filled cooperation with God’s divine initiative.1 In what specific area of your life might God be inviting you to give your “yes” and cooperate with His grace right now?
  • Draft Response: This is a deeply personal question. Mary’s fiat was a response to a specific invitation from God that changed the course of her life. We can reflect on our own lives and ask where God is extending an invitation. It might be a call to forgive someone, to take on a new responsibility at church or in the community, to change a harmful habit, to be more generous, or to trust Him in a situation filled with uncertainty. Like Mary, our role is not to initiate the plan, but to give our faith-filled consent and allow God’s “gracious divine initiative” to work through us.1
  1. The Incarnation means the eternal Son of God took on a full human nature—He “became man”.1 How does the reality that God knows human existence from the inside—with its joys, sorrows, and struggles—deepen your trust in Him?

Draft Response: The fact that Jesus “became man” means God is not an impassive, distant observer of the human condition. He has experienced it himself. He knows fatigue, friendship, betrayal, grief, and physical pain not by observation, but by participation. This reality can build a profound sense of solidarity and trust. We can approach him in prayer with the confidence that he truly understands our human experience. It removes any sense that God is “out of touch” with our reality and assures us that in our suffering and our joy, we have a high priest who can truly empathize with us because he lived a fully human life.

When Time Allows Reflect on the Posts in Library and Musings

Sharing

Jesus last words on Earth were to his disciples, can be found in Matthew Chap 28 when Jesus told his disciples, “Then Jesus approached and said to them, “All power in heaven and on earth has been given to me. Go, therefore, and make disciples of all nations, baptizing them in the name of the Father, and of the Son, and of the holy Spirit, teaching them to observe all that I have commanded you. And behold, I am with you always, until the end of the age.”

Jesus calls all of us to share in his redemptive mission here on Earth. I would ask you to share this Scripture reflection with your family, your friends and your acquaintances, and then share it with a couple of individuals that you may may not be comfortable sharing with, keeping in mind always the words of Jesus, And behold, I am with you always, until the end of the age

Author was assisted by AI in the drafting of this Post

Scroll to Top